Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the quality, integrity, and relevance of scholarship published by LHJ. The journal expects reviewers to provide fair, constructive, evidence based, and confidential assessments that assist editors in making informed decisions and help authors improve their work.
A reviewer should accept an assignment only where they possess sufficient expertise to assess the manuscript or a clearly defined part of it. If the manuscript falls outside their competence, the reviewer should promptly inform the editor.
Reviewers should also notify the editor if they cannot complete the assessment within the agreed period. They must not delegate the review to another person without the editor’s prior permission.
Review reports must focus on the manuscript’s academic content. Reviewers should identify strengths, weaknesses, methodological limitations, unsupported claims, relevant omissions, and areas requiring clarification.
Comments must be professional and respectful. Personal attacks, discriminatory remarks, speculative allegations, and language intended to humiliate or intimidate authors are unacceptable.
Where criticism is made, reviewers should explain its scholarly basis and, where practicable, suggest a constructive way to address the concern.
Reviewers should alert the editor to concerns relating to possible plagiarism, redundant publication, fabricated or manipulated data, unattributed use of published material, questionable research practices, inappropriate authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other potential breaches of research integrity.
Reviewers should not independently investigate or publicly accuse authors of misconduct. Concerns should be communicated confidentially to the editor, who will determine the appropriate next steps.
Reviewers may recommend additional literature where it is materially relevant to the manuscript. Recommendations must be justified by scholarly relevance rather than personal interest, professional rivalry, or an attempt to increase the reviewer’s own citation count.
Reviewers must not insist on unnecessary citations to their own work or to a particular publication without a legitimate academic reason. Citation manipulation and coercive citation practices are inconsistent with the journal’s commitment to research integrity.
Reviewers must not disclose confidential manuscript content or use unpublished findings for personal, professional, commercial, or research advantage.
Reviewers must not submit confidential manuscripts, reviewer reports, author identities, or associated unpublished research materials to generative artificial intelligence tools where the submission could expose confidential information to an external service. Reviewers must not use AI generated assessments as a substitute for their own critical evaluation.
If an AI tool is permitted for a limited administrative purpose, the reviewer remains responsible for confidentiality, accuracy, and compliance with the journal’s instructions.
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or reasonably perceived conflict of interest. Relevant circumstances may include recent collaboration, a supervisory or mentoring relationship, close personal relationships, direct professional competition, financial interests, institutional dependence, or involvement in the research being assessed.
The editor will determine whether the reviewer may proceed or whether an alternative reviewer should be appointed.
A useful review report should ordinarily include:
Reviewers should distinguish between essential revisions and optional suggestions. They should not demand changes that are unrelated to the manuscript’s scholarly purpose.