Research Misconduct Policy

LHJ expects all submitted and published research to be conducted and reported honestly. Research misconduct concerns may arise in doctrinal legal scholarship, empirical social science, interdisciplinary research, policy analysis, and other forms of academic inquiry.

The journal distinguishes deliberate or reckless misconduct from honest error, reasonable academic disagreement, methodological limitations, and differences of interpretation. The existence of an allegation does not establish that misconduct has occurred.

Forms of Potential Misconduct

Potential research misconduct includes, but is not limited to:

  1. Fabrication of research data, sources, interviews, observations, cases, or findings.
  2. Falsification or manipulation of data, evidence, images, documents, or research procedures.
  3. Plagiarism or serious unattributed appropriation.
  4. Manipulation or misrepresentation of legal authorities, quotations, empirical results, or source materials.
  5. Inappropriate authorship, including false attribution or omission of individuals who meet the applicable authorship criteria.
  6. Undisclosed duplicate or redundant publication.
  7. Deliberate manipulation of peer review or provision of false reviewer identities.
  8. Undisclosed conflicts of interest that materially compromise the reliability or integrity of the work.
  9. Improper acquisition, use, disclosure, or representation of confidential or personal information.
  10. Serious violations of research ethics or applicable legal requirements.
  11. Fabrication of references or use of citations that do not support the claims for which they are cited.
  12. Material misrepresentation of the role of AI tools in producing research content, evidence, or analysis.

Reporting Concerns

Concerns about potential misconduct may be communicated to the editorial office with supporting information where available. Reports should identify the relevant manuscript or publication and explain the nature of the concern.

LHJ may decline to act on allegations that are purely speculative, unsupported, abusive, or unrelated to the integrity of the scholarly record. However, the absence of complete documentation will not automatically prevent preliminary assessment where a concern appears credible and sufficiently specific.

Preliminary Assessment and Investigation

The journal will undertake a preliminary assessment to determine whether the concern warrants further action. Where appropriate, the journal may seek an explanation from the corresponding author, request supporting documentation, consult independent experts, or contact the relevant institution.

The journal may pause editorial processing while a serious concern is assessed. If the manuscript has already been published, LHJ may consider a temporary notice or expression of concern where the circumstances justify informing readers of an unresolved issue.

Institutional Responsibility

The journal’s investigation is primarily directed towards determining the appropriate editorial response and protecting the scholarly record. It does not replace a formal institutional investigation where one is required.

Where appropriate, LHJ may refer the matter to the author’s institution, research organisation, funder, or other competent body. The journal will consider the findings of such investigations while retaining responsibility for its own editorial decisions.

Possible Outcomes

Depending on the evidence and seriousness of the concern, possible outcomes include:

  1. No further action where the concern is not substantiated.
  2. A request for clarification or correction.
  3. Rejection of a manuscript.
  4. Correction of a published article.
  5. Publication of an expression of concern.
  6. Retraction of a published article.
  7. Referral to an appropriate institution or authority.
  8. Other proportionate action necessary to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.

LHJ will document material decisions and communicate outcomes to relevant parties where appropriate and legally permissible.