Artificial Intelligence Policy

LHJ recognises that artificial intelligence tools, including generative AI systems, may be used in research, data analysis, language assistance, literature exploration, and manuscript preparation. The journal permits responsible and transparent use of such tools where appropriate, while requiring authors to preserve the accuracy, originality, accountability, and integrity of scholarly work.

The use of an AI tool does not transfer responsibility for a manuscript from its human authors to the tool or its developer.

AI Tools Cannot Be Authors

AI systems and generative AI tools cannot be listed as authors or co authors of a manuscript. Authorship requires human accountability, the ability to approve the final work, responsibility for addressing questions about accuracy and integrity, and other scholarly responsibilities that AI systems cannot independently fulfil.

Authors remain responsible for all material submitted under their names, including content drafted, edited, translated, summarised, or otherwise assisted by AI.

Disclosure of AI Use

Authors must disclose material use of generative AI in preparing a manuscript where such use contributes to substantive text, analysis, interpretation, translation, coding, research design, data processing, or other material aspects of the work.

The disclosure should identify the tool or system used, explain the purpose of its use, and describe the relevant stage of the research or writing process. Where necessary, authors should explain how the output was verified and how human oversight was maintained.

A disclosure does not replace the requirement to cite original sources, verify factual claims, or comply with applicable research ethics and copyright requirements.

Routine spelling correction, grammar checking, or formatting assistance may not require a separate disclosure unless the journal specifies otherwise or the tool has materially altered the substance of the manuscript.

Accuracy and Verification

Authors must independently verify AI generated content before submission. They remain responsible for the accuracy of legal authorities, case citations, statutory references, empirical data, quotations, research findings, and bibliographic information.

AI systems may generate fabricated citations, misstate legal principles, misrepresent judicial decisions, produce inaccurate summaries, or introduce unsupported claims. Such errors must be identified and corrected before submission.

Authors must not present fabricated data, invented interviews, false references, nonexistent cases, or unverified AI generated content as authentic research.

Research Data and Confidential Information

Authors must not enter confidential, privileged, personally identifiable, sensitive, or otherwise restricted information into an AI service where such use is unauthorised or may compromise privacy, confidentiality, research ethics, contractual obligations, or applicable law.

Particular caution is required for legal case files, confidential institutional records, research participant information, unpublished datasets, privileged communications, and sensitive information concerning vulnerable individuals.

Authors are responsible for determining whether a tool’s data handling arrangements are compatible with the legal and ethical requirements applicable to their research.

AI in Research Methods and Data Analysis

Where AI tools materially contribute to data collection, coding, classification, statistical analysis, content analysis, translation, or other research procedures, authors must provide sufficient methodological information to allow readers to understand the tool’s role and assess the reliability of the findings.

Disclosure may include the system name, version where available, relevant settings or parameters, the nature of human oversight, validation procedures, and known limitations. The level of detail should be proportionate to the tool’s significance in the research.

AI generated analysis must not be represented as independently verified empirical evidence without appropriate validation.

AI Use by Reviewers and Editors

Reviewers and editors must protect the confidentiality of manuscripts and unpublished research. They must not upload confidential submission materials to external AI systems where doing so could expose manuscript content, reviewer information, author identities, or research data.

AI tools must not replace the independent scholarly judgment required for peer review or editorial decision making. Editors and reviewers remain responsible for the accuracy, fairness, confidentiality, and integrity of their assessments.

AI Detection Tools

AI detection tools may produce inaccurate results and should not be treated as conclusive proof that a manuscript was written by AI or that misconduct occurred.

LHJ will not base a finding of misconduct solely on an automated AI detection score. Where a credible concern arises, the journal may request an explanation, examine relevant evidence, and assess the circumstances in accordance with its publication ethics and research misconduct policies.

Consequences of Non Disclosure or Misuse

Failure to disclose material AI use, fabrication of content or evidence, misrepresentation of AI generated work, or other serious misuse may result in a request for clarification, revision, rejection, correction, retraction, or further investigation, depending on the circumstances.

The journal will distinguish between honest mistakes, limited and properly supervised assistance, inadequate disclosure, and deliberate or reckless misrepresentation.