The editorial decision process is intended to ensure consistency, independence, transparency, and accountability in the handling of manuscripts submitted to LHJ.
The editor responsible for a manuscript must assess its suitability for publication by considering the manuscript itself, the reviewers’ reports, the journal’s aims and scope, relevant ethical requirements, and any applicable editorial policies.
Reviewers provide expert advice but do not determine publication outcomes. The responsible editor retains decision making authority, subject to the journal’s governance arrangements and any applicable conflict of interest safeguards.
A submission may be declined before external review if it does not satisfy the journal’s scope, minimum scholarly requirements, submission requirements, or ethical standards.
Where external review is undertaken, the editor must evaluate the substance and quality of the reports rather than merely count favourable or unfavourable recommendations. If reports materially conflict, the editor may seek clarification, obtain an additional independent review, or make a reasoned decision on the available evidence.
When revisions are requested, authors must respond to the comments in a clear and organised manner. The revised manuscript may be returned to the original reviewers or assessed by the editor, depending on the nature of the revisions.
A revised submission may be declined if the authors do not adequately address essential concerns or if new issues arise during reassessment. An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.
A manuscript may be accepted only after the responsible editor has determined that it meets the journal’s scholarly and ethical requirements.
Following acceptance, the manuscript may undergo copyediting, typesetting, reference checking, author proof review, and other production procedures. Authors remain responsible for checking the accuracy of author names, affiliations, funding information, declarations, tables, figures, and other material presented in proofs.
Changes to authorship or substantive content after acceptance require editorial approval and may require additional documentation or assessment.
An editor must not make or control a decision on a manuscript where a conflict of interest could compromise impartiality. Such manuscripts must be handled by another appropriately qualified and independent editor.
Where the Editor in Chief submits a manuscript to LHJ, the journal must assign the submission to an independent editor who has authority over the review and decision process. The submitting editor must not access confidential reviewer identities or participate in the decision beyond any role ordinarily available to the author.
The journal should maintain appropriate records of submission dates, editorial assessments, reviewer invitations, review reports, author responses, decisions, declarations, and material correspondence. Access to these records must be restricted to authorised individuals and managed in accordance with applicable privacy and retention requirements.