LHJ is committed to preserving the accuracy, transparency, and reliability of the scholarly record. Where a published article is found to contain a material error, or where credible concerns arise regarding its reliability or integrity, the journal will assess the matter and determine whether corrective action is necessary.
Editorial action will be proportionate to the nature of the problem, the evidence available, the effect on the article’s conclusions, and the interests of readers and affected parties.
A correction may be appropriate where an error in a published article can be rectified without invalidating the overall reliability of the work.
Examples may include material errors in author details, affiliations, funding declarations, references, data presentation, figures, or other information. The need for a correction depends on whether the error affects the interpretation, attribution, reproducibility, or integrity of the article.
Corrections must clearly identify the article concerned, describe the relevant error, and explain the correction made. Where practicable, the correction notice should be linked to the original article, and the original article should link to the correction notice.
Minor typographical or formatting errors that do not affect meaning may be corrected through routine production procedures without a separate public notice, subject to the journal’s editorial practice.
Retraction may be considered where the available evidence establishes that a published article is substantially unreliable or where serious ethical or publication integrity concerns warrant removal of its status as reliable scholarship.
Possible grounds include:
Retraction is a mechanism for correcting the scholarly record, not necessarily a disciplinary sanction against an author. The journal will assess each case on its merits and will not treat a retraction as automatic proof of personal misconduct beyond the findings established in the relevant case.
A retraction notice should identify the article, explain the reason for retraction to the extent appropriate, and distinguish between established facts and unresolved allegations.
Where practicable, the notice will be linked to the original article, and the original article will remain accessible with a clear retraction designation. The journal should not silently remove or alter the scholarly record merely because an article has been retracted.
Any exceptional removal of article content must be justified by legal obligations, serious risks to individuals, or other compelling circumstances and should be documented appropriately.
An expression of concern may be issued where a credible and potentially serious issue has arisen but the available evidence is insufficient for a final decision, or where an investigation is ongoing and readers need to be alerted to a material uncertainty.
The notice should explain the nature of the concern without presenting unproven allegations as established facts. Where appropriate, the journal will update the record when further information becomes available.
Authors seeking to withdraw a manuscript before publication must submit a written request to the editorial office. Withdrawal will be subject to confirmation that the manuscript is not simultaneously being processed for publication elsewhere and that the request is made by an appropriately authorised author.
Where a manuscript has already entered peer review, the journal may require clarification of the reasons for withdrawal. Withdrawal requests do not remove the authors’ responsibility to address credible allegations of misconduct arising during the editorial process.
Where a concern arises after publication, LHJ may consider information from authors, readers, reviewers, institutions, research organisations, or other credible sources.
The journal will assess the reliability and relevance of the evidence, seek clarification where appropriate, and determine the necessary editorial response. The journal may take action even if the original authors disagree with the proposed outcome, provided that the decision is reached through a fair and adequately documented process.