LHJ recognises the importance of providing a fair process for complaints and appeals relating to editorial decisions, peer review, publication ethics, editorial conduct, and the application of journal policies.
Complaints and appeals must be handled impartially, confidentially, and within a reasonable period. The procedure is intended to provide a meaningful opportunity for review without undermining legitimate editorial independence.
This policy may apply to complaints concerning:
Complaints should be submitted in writing to the journal’s official editorial contact. The complainant should identify the relevant manuscript, article, decision, or incident and provide a clear description of the concern, including supporting documentation where available.
The journal may request further information where necessary to assess the complaint. Anonymous complaints may be considered where they contain sufficiently specific and credible information to justify assessment.
Complaints should be expressed in professional language and should focus on identifiable conduct, decisions, or evidence.
The journal will determine whether the complaint falls within its responsibility and whether further examination is warranted. Where appropriate, the complainant may receive acknowledgement and information about the next procedural step.
The journal may decline to pursue a complaint that is demonstrably outside its remit, lacks sufficient detail for meaningful assessment, or repeats a matter that has already been fully considered without presenting materially new information. The reason for declining a substantive complaint should be communicated where appropriate.
An author may appeal an editorial decision where there is a reasonable basis to believe that the decision involved a material factual error, a significant misunderstanding of the manuscript, an undisclosed conflict of interest, a serious procedural irregularity, or an inconsistent application of journal policy.
An appeal should identify the specific grounds and explain why reconsideration is justified. Mere disagreement with a reviewer’s scholarly opinion, without a substantive reason, will not ordinarily justify reversal of a decision.
The journal may refer an appeal to an independent editor who was not responsible for the original decision. The appeal reviewer may examine the manuscript, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and the grounds raised by the author.
A complaint involving the Editor in Chief or another editor must be reviewed by an appropriately independent person where practicable. An individual whose conduct is directly challenged must not have sole responsibility for determining the outcome of the complaint. Where necessary, the journal may seek independent advice from a suitably qualified person.
Possible outcomes include dismissal of the complaint, clarification of the decision, reconsideration of a procedural matter, correction of an administrative error, further investigation, referral to an appropriate body, or other proportionate action.
The journal will communicate the outcome to the complainant to the extent appropriate, while respecting confidentiality, privacy, and the rights of other parties.
An appeal does not automatically suspend or reverse an editorial decision. The original decision may be upheld where the review finds no material error or procedural defect. The journal’s decision following an appeal will ordinarily be final within its internal editorial process, without prejudice to any applicable legal rights or external procedures.