Peer Review Process

Lex Humanitas Journal (LHJ) is committed to a rigorous, impartial, confidential, and transparent peer review process designed to evaluate the scholarly quality, originality, methodological soundness, legal accuracy, and contribution of submitted manuscripts. The journal’s review framework is intended to uphold academic integrity and ensure that editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit rather than an author’s institutional affiliation, nationality, personal characteristics, professional position, or other irrelevant considerations.

Type of Peer Review

LHJ adopts a double blind peer review model. Under this model, the identities of authors are concealed from reviewers, and the identities of reviewers are concealed from authors during the review process, subject to the practical limitations of maintaining anonymity.

Authors must submit a separate title page containing their names, institutional affiliations, professional details, and corresponding author information. The main manuscript must not contain identifying information that could unnecessarily disclose the authors’ identities. Authors should also review acknowledgements, document properties, self citations, research instruments, supplementary files, and other materials for identifying information where practicable.

Double blind review does not guarantee that reviewers will be unable to infer an author’s identity from a manuscript’s subject, methodology, writing style, or references. Nevertheless, LHJ will take reasonable measures to protect anonymity throughout the editorial process.

Initial Editorial Assessment

Every submission is subject to an initial editorial assessment before external peer review. The editorial office or an authorised editor may examine whether the manuscript:

  1. Falls within the journal’s aims and scope.
  2. Presents an identifiable scholarly question or research objective.
  3. Demonstrates sufficient originality and academic significance.
  4. Uses an appropriate research methodology or analytical framework.
  5. Engages critically with relevant legal, social science, interdisciplinary, or empirical literature.
  6. Observes applicable ethical requirements.
  7. Complies with the journal’s submission and manuscript preparation requirements.
  8. Includes the required declarations concerning authorship, funding, conflicts of interest, data availability, and the use of artificial intelligence, where applicable.
  9. Is sufficiently developed to justify external review.
  10. Raises concerns relating to plagiarism, redundant publication, research misconduct, citation manipulation, or other breaches of publication ethics.

A manuscript may be declined at the initial assessment stage where it falls outside the journal’s scope, lacks sufficient scholarly substance, fails to satisfy essential submission requirements, or raises unresolved ethical concerns. Such a decision does not necessarily imply that the manuscript is unsuitable for every other publication.

Selection of Reviewers

Where a manuscript proceeds to external review, LHJ will seek reviewers with relevant subject expertise and the capacity to evaluate the manuscript independently. Reviewer selection may take account of disciplinary knowledge, methodological competence, relevant publication experience, and potential conflicts of interest.

Reviewers must disclose any circumstances that could compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, their impartiality. A reviewer should decline an assignment where a personal, professional, financial, institutional, supervisory, collaborative, or other relationship could materially affect independent assessment.

The journal should ordinarily seek two independent external reviews for research articles, subject to the availability of qualified reviewers and the nature of the submission. Additional reviews may be sought where reports conflict, specialist expertise is required, or significant methodological or ethical concerns arise. The final review workflow must be implemented consistently through the journal’s editorial system.

Criteria for Evaluation

Reviewers may assess manuscripts against the following criteria:

  1. Originality and contribution to existing scholarship.
  2. Clarity and significance of the research question.
  3. Engagement with relevant literature and legal authorities.
  4. Accuracy of legal interpretation and use of primary sources, where applicable.
  5. Theoretical coherence and conceptual clarity.
  6. Suitability and transparency of the research methodology.
  7. Reliability of evidence, data, sources, and analytical reasoning.
  8. Ethical compliance, including consent, confidentiality, and protection of research participants where applicable.
  9. Quality of analysis and strength of the conclusions.
  10. Relevance to the journal’s aims and scope.
  11. Quality of academic writing, organisation, referencing, and presentation.
  12. Limitations of the study and the extent to which the conclusions are supported by the evidence.

The evaluation criteria may be adapted to the manuscript type. For example, a doctrinal legal article may be assessed primarily on legal reasoning, interpretation of authorities, and analytical contribution, whereas an empirical social science article may require closer examination of research design, sampling, data collection, analysis, and limitations.

Possible Review Outcomes

Following review, a manuscript may receive one of the following recommendations:

  1. Accept without further substantive revision.
  2. Accept subject to minor revisions.
  3. Invite major revisions and further assessment.
  4. Decline the manuscript.

A recommendation from a reviewer does not constitute a final editorial decision. The responsible editor must independently evaluate the reports, the manuscript, and the applicable editorial policies before communicating a decision.

Where revision is invited, authors must submit a revised manuscript and a point by point response explaining how each substantive comment has been addressed. Where an author disagrees with a recommendation, the response should provide a reasoned academic explanation.

Confidentiality During Review

Manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential scholarly documents. Reviewers must not disclose, circulate, reproduce, or use unpublished material for personal advantage or to benefit another person or institution.

Editors must limit access to submitted manuscripts to individuals who require access for legitimate editorial, peer review, technical, or integrity related purposes. Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or identifiable research materials to public artificial intelligence systems or other external services where doing so could compromise confidentiality.

Editorial Independence

Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly quality, relevance, originality, ethical compliance, and the journal’s published policies. Decisions must not be influenced by payment of publication charges, commercial interests, institutional pressure, personal relationships, or the authors’ perceived status.

Where an editor has a conflict of interest, the manuscript must be assigned to an appropriately independent editor. The journal must maintain suitable records of editorial decisions and material communications in accordance with its operational and record keeping procedures.

Review Timelines

LHJ will seek to process submissions without unnecessary delay. Actual timelines may vary according to manuscript complexity, reviewer availability, the need for additional expertise, revision requirements, and editorial workload.