Manuscript Preparation

Referencing and Formatting Standard

LHJ proposes to adopt the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association, Seventh Edition (APA 7th edition) as its general style for manuscript formatting, in-text citations, and reference lists.

Because the Journal publishes legal scholarship as well as social science research, APA 7 must be supplemented by a specific legal citation guide for legislation, judicial decisions, treaties, and other legal materials.

Page Layout and Text Formatting

Unless otherwise instructed for a particular article category, manuscripts should follow this standard:

ElementLHJ specification
File typeMicrosoft Word .docx
Page sizeA4
FontTimes New Roman, 12 point
Margins1 inch (2.54 cm) on all sides
Main text spacingDouble spaced
Paragraph alignmentLeft aligned, ragged right
Paragraph indentationFirst line 0.5 inch (1.27 cm), except where APA 7 specifies otherwise
Page numberingConsecutive page numbers in the upper right corner
Main textConsistent font, spacing, and heading hierarchy
AbstractSeparate section, ordinarily 150 to 200 words
KeywordsFive to seven (Alphabetical order)
In-text citationsAPA 7 author-date style, supplemented by legal citation instructions
ReferencesSeparate reference list
FootnotesConcise content or copyright notes
Tables and figuresNumbered and titled, with source and permission details where applicable
LanguageAcademic English

Authors should use the word processor’s standard paragraph and footnote functions rather than manually creating spacing with repeated spaces or line breaks.

Title and Headings

The manuscript title must identify the principal subject clearly and avoid unsupported claims or unnecessary abbreviations.

Authors should use a consistent heading hierarchy. Under APA 7, headings follow a defined five-level structure, distinguished by formatting and alignment.

The following general hierarchy should be applied consistently:

  1. Level 1: Centred, bold, title case.
  2. Level 2: Left aligned, bold, title case.
  3. Level 3: Left aligned, bold italic, title case.
  4. Level 4: Indented, bold, title case, ending with a period; the paragraph continues on the same line.
  5. Level 5: Indented, bold italic, title case, ending with a period; the paragraph continues on the same line.

Authors should not use heading levels merely to create visual variety. The hierarchy must reflect the logical organisation of the argument.

Abstract

Research articles should ordinarily include an abstract of 150 to 200 words.

The abstract should identify:

  1. The research problem or central question.
  2. The principal objective or purpose.
  3. The methodology or analytical approach.
  4. The principal findings, arguments, or conclusions.
  5. The article’s contribution to scholarship.

The abstract must accurately represent the manuscript and should not introduce findings, claims, or conclusions that are not developed in the main text.

For empirical research, the abstract should summarise the study’s design and principal findings. For doctrinal legal research, it should identify the legal question, principal authorities or analytical approach where appropriate, and central argument. For theoretical or conceptual work, it should state the conceptual problem and the principal contribution.

The abstract should ordinarily avoid citations, footnotes, undefined abbreviations, and lengthy background discussion.

Keywords

Authors should provide five to seven keywords immediately after the abstract.

Keywords should identify the principal legal field, research problem, analytical approach, jurisdiction, or subject area. They should support scholarly discoverability and should not simply repeat the entire title.

For example, a paper examining algorithmic decision-making and administrative fairness might use keywords such as algorithmic governance, administrative law, procedural fairness, artificial intelligence, and public accountability. These are illustrative only; authors must select keywords that accurately describe their own work.

Manuscript Structure

The structure should be appropriate to the article category.

A research article may ordinarily include:

  1. Introduction.
  2. Research problem and objectives.
  3. Review of relevant scholarship.
  4. Methodology or analytical framework.
  5. Main analysis, findings, or discussion.
  6. Limitations, where applicable.
  7. Conclusion.
  8. References.
  9. Appendices or supplementary materials, where necessary.

This sequence is not mandatory for every article. Case comments, doctrinal studies, theoretical papers, and book reviews may require a different structure.

The introduction should explain the research problem, its significance, and the article’s purpose. The main body should develop the argument systematically. The conclusion should follow from the analysis and should not introduce major new evidence without explanation.

Research Questions and Objectives

Research questions and objectives must be clear, focused, and consistent with the manuscript’s scope.

Authors should avoid research questions that are too broad to be addressed adequately within the article’s word limit. Where several questions are addressed, the relationship between them should be explained.

The analysis must answer the questions posed or explain why a question cannot be resolved fully within the study’s limitations.

Methodology

Authors must explain the methodology or analytical approach where relevant.

For doctrinal legal research, the manuscript should identify the relevant legal sources and explain how legislation, judicial decisions, constitutional provisions, treaties, or other authorities are interpreted and analysed.

For comparative legal research, authors should justify the choice of jurisdictions, identify the criteria for comparison, and explain the relevance of differences in legal and institutional context.

For empirical research, authors should describe the research design, participants or units of analysis, sampling or selection methods, data collection procedures, analytical methods, and relevant limitations.

For qualitative research, authors should explain the sources of qualitative evidence and the method of interpretation or coding where applicable.

For quantitative research, authors should provide sufficient information about variables, measures, data sources, statistical methods, and limitations to permit informed evaluation.

For systematic or structured reviews, authors should explain the databases or sources searched, search terms where relevant, inclusion and exclusion criteria, selection process, and method of synthesis.

For theoretical or conceptual research, authors should identify the conceptual framework and explain how the argument is developed and assessed.

Authors must not claim to have used a method that was not actually undertaken. Methodological statements should be specific enough to allow readers to assess the credibility of the analysis.

APA 7 In-Text Citations

LHJ’s general rule is that citations to ordinary scholarly sources should use the APA 7 author-date system.

Paraphrase

Example:

Institutional accountability is frequently discussed as a component of effective public governance (Sharma, 2024).

Narrative citation

Example:

Sharma (2024) examines the relationship between institutional accountability and public governance.

Direct quotation

Example:

Sharma (2024) stated that “the exact quoted words must be reproduced accurately” (p. 45).

The examples are illustrative and do not refer to a verified publication.

For direct quotations, authors should provide a page number where the source is paginated. Where page numbers are unavailable, an appropriate locator, such as a paragraph number or section heading, should be supplied when possible.

For two-author works, both surnames should appear in every citation. For works with three or more authors, the first author’s surname followed by et al. should ordinarily be used from the first citation, subject to APA 7 rules.

For an organisational author, use the organisation’s name. An abbreviation may be introduced where appropriate and used consistently thereafter.

Citations must correspond to the reference list. Authors must not cite works they have not verified or use a citation merely because another publication has cited it.

APA 7 Reference List

The reference list should appear after the main text and before appendices, subject to the Journal’s final production instructions.

Authors must ensure that each entry contains the bibliographic information required for the source type and that all details are accurate.

Journal article example

Sharma, R. (2024). Institutional accountability and public governance. Journal of Legal Studies, 18(2), 101–125. https://doi.org/10.xxxx/xxxxx

Book example

Sharma, R. (2024). Law, institutions, and social change. Example Academic Press.

Chapter in an edited book example

Sharma, R. (2024). Legal institutions and social transformation. In P. Kumar (Ed.), Contemporary perspectives on law and society (pp. 55–78). Example Academic Press.

Organisational report example

Example Research Institute. (2024). Annual report on governance and legal reform. https://example.org/report

These examples are templates only. They are not real publications and must not be used as actual references.

For online sources, authors should include a DOI or URL where required by APA 7. A DOI should be included in its prescribed URL form. Retrieval dates should be provided only where required by the style, such as for certain unarchived content that changes over time.

The reference list should be alphabetised by the surname of the first author or the name of the responsible organisation. Authors must use hanging indentation and consistent punctuation and capitalisation.

Legal Authorities, Statutes, and Judicial Decisions

Legal authorities must be cited according to the Journal’s supplementary legal citation guide.

For judicial decisions, authors should identify the case name, year, court or jurisdiction, and official or recognised report citation where available. Statutory citations should identify the enactment and the relevant section, article, or provision. International instruments should be identified by their official titles and relevant provisions.

Authors must distinguish accurately between a court’s holding, obiter observations, submissions by the parties, and the author’s own interpretation.

Where a judgment is quoted, the wording must be checked against an authoritative text. A secondary source should not be presented as though it were the judgment itself.

Footnotes: Purpose and Use

LHJ permits footnotes for concise explanatory information and copyright acknowledgements. Footnotes should not serve as the principal citation system.

APA 7 recognises content footnotes and copyright permission footnotes. Authors should use them only where they add meaningful information or provide necessary rights information.

Content footnotes may explain a qualification, define a specialised term, or provide supplementary information that would interrupt the main argument.

Copyright footnotes or notes may be needed to acknowledge permission for reproduced or adapted material, depending on the source, applicable licence, and Journal instructions.

Footnotes must not be used to hide sources, avoid citations, or transfer essential analysis out of the main text.

Footnote Numbering and Formatting

Authors should observe the following proposed LHJ rules:

  1. Insert footnotes using the automatic footnote function in the word processor.
  2. Number footnotes consecutively using Arabic numerals.
  3. Place the superscript footnote marker after the relevant punctuation, subject to APA 7 conventions.
  4. Do not place a footnote marker in a heading.
  5. Keep each footnote concise and focused on one principal point.
  6. Use the same formatting consistently throughout the manuscript.
  7. Ensure that copyright notes contain the information required by the Journal and the applicable rights holder.
  8. Check that footnotes are complete and appear correctly in the submitted file.

Authors should not impose a fixed maximum number of footnotes unless LHJ formally adopts such a limit. Necessity and relevance are more appropriate editorial criteria than an arbitrary numerical cap.

Tables, Figures, and Other Visual Material

Tables and figures should be included only where they materially assist the analysis or presentation of the research.

Each table or figure should have a number and informative title. Any abbreviations, measures, or qualifications needed to interpret it should be explained in a note.

Where the visual material is original, authors should indicate the basis of the data where relevant. Where it is reproduced or adapted, the source must be cited and the necessary permission obtained.

Authors must ensure that tables, figures, and charts do not misrepresent data or omit qualifications necessary to understand the findings.

Appendices and Supplementary Material

Appendices may contain material necessary for transparency or verification but not suitable for inclusion in the main text. Examples include research instruments, supplementary tables, coding frameworks, or additional methodological information.

Appendices should be labelled consistently and referred to in the manuscript. Supplementary material should not be used to conceal essential findings or information required to evaluate the central argument.

Authors must ensure that supplementary material does not disclose confidential or personal information without a lawful and appropriate basis.

Final Formatting Check

Before submission, authors should verify that:

  1. The manuscript uses the approved font, margins, spacing, and page numbering.
  2. Heading levels are consistent.
  3. The abstract and keywords meet the prescribed limits.
  4. All quotations are accurate and attributed.
  5. APA 7 citations correspond with the reference list.
  6. Legal authorities are accurately cited.
  7. Footnotes are necessary and correctly numbered.
  8. Tables and figures have titles, notes, sources, and permissions where required.
  9. The anonymised manuscript contains no avoidable identifying information.
  10. The file opens correctly and contains no unresolved comments or tracked changes.